Car Insurance Denies Claim Saying Driver was Driving for Hire and Loses

Car insurance is designed to help accident victims obtain compensation for their injuries after a Georgia car accident. In practice car insurance companies will look for any excuse to deny insurance claims. Insurance companies are operated on a for-profit basis, and the viability of the company relies on it taking in more money in premiums than it pays out in claims. Thus, insurance adjusters are often in the position of reviewing claims with an eye toward denying them, or settling them for as little money as possible.

Insurance ContractIf an insurance company denies a motorist’s claim, the motorist has the option of filing a Georgia personal injury lawsuit against the insurance company, seeking a court order that the company honor the contractual obligations in the insurance contract. However, insurance companies are experienced at defending against these claims, and they have teams of attorneys to assist them in litigation. Thus, an experienced Georgia personal injury attorney is an invaluable asset for victims.

A recent case illustrates the efforts of one insurance company to avoid paying out on a motorist’s claim.

The Facts of the Case

The plaintiff was insured by the defendant insurance company. On occasion, the plaintiff would provide transportation for an elderly woman for compensation. On the day of the accident, the plaintiff was driving when he saw the elderly woman walking along the side of the road. The plaintiff pulled over and asked her if she wanted a ride into town. The two did not discuss payment, but the woman later explained that she did intend on paying the plaintiff for the ride.As the plaintiff drove the woman into town, another motorist opened his car door into the plaintiff’s car. The noise from the minor collision caused the plaintiff to jerk his neck around to see what had occurred. The plaintiff was injured as a result and filed a claim with his insurance company, seeking compensation for his injuries.The insurance company denied his claim, arguing that the accident was not covered under the plaintiff’s policy. 

The insurance company claimed that by giving the woman a ride for money, the plaintiff was operating his car for hire and pursuant to the insurance contract, coverage did not apply to a vehicle when it was being operated as a “public or livery conveyance,” which essentially means for hire.

The court acknowledged that the woman usually paid the plaintiff for a ride and that she intended to pay him this time as well. However, the court also noted that the burden is on the insurance company to prove the facts establishing that an accident falls within an exception to coverage. Here, the court held, the insurance company was unable to prove that the plaintiff made his car available to the general public. The court held that, giving the benefit of the doubt to the plaintiff, which is required in a defense motion for summary judgment, the plaintiff had only agreed to provide transportation services for the elderly woman, instead of the general public. That being the case, the court held that the exception to coverage did not apply.

The key holding of the case is, just because he charged her for gas every now and again does not mean he is a for hire public driver.

Have You Been Injured in a Georgia Car Accident?

If you or a loved one has recently been injured in a Georgia car accident, and you are currently dealing with a difficult or dishonest insurance company, Attorney Christopher Simon can help. Christopher Simon has extensive experience representing Georgia victims and their families in a wide range of personal injury and wrongful death cases, including those involving difficult insurance companies. Attorney Simon is not afraid to take on even the biggest insurance companies, and he will not hesitate to take your case to trial if a fair settlement offer is not made. Call 404-259-7635 to schedule a free consultation today.
Client Reviews
★★★★★
My wife and I were hit by a tractor trailer in 2014. After extensive research online, we were deeply impressed with the various reviews we read on Google and Avvo and chose Chris to represent us. We could not have a made a better decision. Chris and his firm treated us like we were their only clients, soothed our worries, and instantly gained our trust. Chris settled both of our cases for more than we expected.
★★★★★
A co-worker of my wife recommended Chris to us. At the very beginning Chris showed that he cared and his knowledge is priceless. Going through this process can be aggravating but Chris did a great job guiding me through this and was always available to answer my questions. Chris fought to get what I deserved even though at times I wanted to give up. Tracy
★★★★★
I want to express my deepest sense of gratitude and appreciation to Attorney Chris Simon & Attorney Chris Carsten, for all the hard work that they put forth into my case (car accident filed after being hit by drunk driver). Their attention to detail and professionalism far surpasses their firm's reputation. Because of their diligence and dedication to their craft, they were able to bring my case to a successful close, one that I could live with. You will not find a better team for your case. Should I have a need for their services again in the future, or know of anyone looking for a top notch Auto Accident Law Firm, I would not hesitate to recommend them!!!! Elle
★★★★★
Wow...Chris is a very good attorney. Me and my son was in a very bad car accident an I was clueless on how to handle the situation. It's very hard to find an attorney who allows you to contact them personally instead of you contacting their asst. I was told that I didn't have a case because the hosiptal put a lien on my acct. Chris prove different and I was able to file my case with the insurance company. The process was very quickly and Im glad I selected the right attorney..Thanks Chris A Car Accident client
★★★★★
Chris is a great lawyer and the most people friendly attorney I have ever delt with. He handled my case with great attention to detail and did so in a very short period of time. He is very consice, efficient, patient and understanding. He has a strong passion for what he does and he does it well. I recommend Chris Simon as legal representation for anyone who has suffreed damages or a loss at the negligence of others. He really cares about you and your case. A Car Accident client